top of page

Top 10 Best Pizza Spots in Hamilton: A Slice Above the Rest

Writer's picture: Faysal JaaliFaysal Jaali

Hamilton boasts a vibrant and diverse pizza scene, offering everything from authentic deep-dish to innovative plant-based options. Here are some of the city's top-rated pizzerias, celebrated for their exceptional flavors and unique offerings:



1. Chicago Style Pizza

chicago style pizza hamilton
Credit: Gallo Design Consultants

A Hamilton institution since the 1970s, Chicago Style Pizza brings the authentic taste of Chicago's deep-dish to Canada. Renowned for their hefty, cheese-laden pies, they offer a variety of crusts, including thick, thin, stuffed, white, and regular. Their commitment to crafting exceptional dough daily ensures a memorable dining experience.


2. MaiPai

MaiPai tiki
Credit: Cekan

For those seeking a unique twist, MaiPai serves Detroit-style pizzas characterized by their thick, crispy crusts and airy interiors. As a tiki bar, MaiPai pairs its inventive pizzas with elaborate cocktails, creating a vibrant and enjoyable atmosphere.



3. Shorty's Pizza

Shorty's Pizza
Credit: Shorty's Pizza

Emulating the classic New York-style, Shorty's Pizza offers foldable, thin-crust pizzas with a slightly sweet, tangy sauce. Their retro ambiance and dedication to quality make it a beloved spot for pizza enthusiasts.


4. Flora Pizzeria

Flora Pizzeria
Credit: yogalexa

Specializing in Roman-style pizzas, Flora Pizzeria crafts rectangular pies with a thin, crunchy crust. Using high-quality, often locally sourced ingredients, they offer a gourmet pizza experience that stands out in Hamilton's culinary landscape.


5. Tony G’s Pizzeria

Tony G’s Pizzeria
Credit: Tony G’s Pizzeria

Located in downtown Hamilton, Tony G’s is celebrated for its New York-style pizzas featuring a foldable, thin crust, tangy tomato sauce, and balanced cheese proportions. Their commitment to quality has earned them a loyal following among locals.


6. Cowabunga Pizzeria

Cowabunga Pizzeria -
Credit: Richard Jean

Gaining international acclaim, Cowabunga Pizzeria's classic New York-style cheese slice was named the best in the world at the 2023 International Pizza Expo. Their dedication to perfecting the balance of crust, cheese, and sauce has firmly placed Hamilton on the global pizza map.



7. Bronzie’s Place

Bronzie’s Place hamilton
Credit: Steve Lemon

A longstanding favorite, Bronzie’s Place offers humble, no-nonsense Italian eats, including flavorful pizzas and homemade pastas. Their commitment to quality and tradition has solidified their reputation over the years.


8. Rise Above Pizzeria

Rise Above Pizza & Wings
Credit: Rise Above Pizzeria

As Hamilton's first and only vegan pizzeria, Rise Above offers plant-based pizzas that rival traditional options. Their innovative approach caters to both vegans and non-vegans seeking delicious, ethical dining choices.


9. Born & Raised

Born & Raised hamilton
Credit: Born & Raised Restaurant 

Born & Raised Restaurant is a popular spot in Hamilton offering a mix of Italian-inspired dishes, including their renowned wood-fired pizzas. Their menu emphasizes fresh, high-quality ingredients, blending traditional techniques with modern flair. Known for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional service, Born & Raised is a must-visit for anyone seeking a premium dining experience in Hamilton.



10. Bread Bar: Bardo

Bread Bar: Bardo hamilton
Credit: The Hamilton Spectator

Earth to Table: Bread Bar, now Bardo, is a farm-to-table pizzeria that emphasizes fresh, local ingredients. Their wood-fired pizzas are made from scratch, with creative toppings that change seasonally. With a cozy atmosphere and commitment to sustainability, it’s a go-to for pizza lovers who appreciate quality and innovation.


Hamilton is home to an incredible variety of pizza spots that cater to every craving, from classic deep-dish to innovative vegan options. With pizzerias like Chicago Style Pizza, MaiPai, and the world-renowned Cowabunga Pizzeria, there’s no shortage of delicious options to explore. Whether you’re seeking a quick slice or a gourmet experience, the best pizza in Hamilton offers something for everyone.


If you’re a local or just visiting, be sure to indulge in Hamilton’s thriving pizza scene. From traditional recipes to creative twists, these pizzerias prove why Hamilton is a destination for pizza lovers. Whether you’re in the mood for Roman-style, New York-style, or even plant-based pies, you’re sure to find the best pizza in Hamilton to satisfy your appetite.


bottom of page